In Pakistan, Workplace Harassment Laws Fail to Deliver Justice

20 Nov, 2026
6 mins read
Photo: iram shehzad via Pexels

Pakistan has spent years building a legal framework against workplace harassment, yet the existence of legislation has not eliminated the fear, humiliation and abuse of authority experienced by employees. For many victims, reporting misconduct can become another ordeal, involving institutional pressure, procedural complications and uncertainty over whether the accused will face meaningful consequences. The problem extends beyond unwanted sexual advances. Intimidation, gender-based humiliation, degrading treatment and the misuse of professional authority can also turn workplaces into hostile environments.

The issue has returned to the centre of Pakistan’s parliamentary debate following a National Assembly resolution adopted on October 30, 2026, reaffirming that workplace harassment is not restricted to sexually motivated conduct. The resolution recognised intimidation, gender discrimination, humiliation, hostile behaviour and the misuse of authority as forms of harassment that deserve legal attention. However, the renewed political emphasis has coincided with another development exposing the complications surrounding the country’s legal protections: a Federal Constitutional Court judgment that has triggered a debate over how the harassment law should be interpreted.

The contradiction is central to Pakistan’s workplace harassment crisis. The country has legislation, an ombudsperson’s office and institutional complaint mechanisms, but questions remain over how consistently these protections operate, whether complainants can obtain timely redress and whether powerful individuals are held accountable.

A law expanded in 2022, a controversy revived in 2026

Pakistan’s Protection against Harassment of Women at the Workplace Act was enacted in 2010. Initially, its principal focus was sexual harassment, including unwelcome sexual advances, requests for sexual favours and sexually demeaning conduct that interfered with professional performance or created an intimidating, hostile or offensive working environment.

Parliament substantially expanded the legislation through the Protection against Harassment of Women at the Workplace (Amendment) Act, 2022. The amendments widened the definition of an employee to include contractual, temporary, part-time, freelance and gig workers, alongside students, artists, performers, sportspersons, domestic workers, apprentices and interns. The law also extended its reach to home-based workers and people working through online or remote businesses.

More significantly, the amendment introduced Section 2(h)(ii), which expressly included discrimination based on gender, whether sexual or non-sexual, within the definition of harassment. This provision recognised that workplace abuse could involve gender-based prejudice, discriminatory behaviour and the misuse of authority without necessarily involving sexual advances.

The amended legislation also widened the definition of a workplace to cover locations beyond conventional offices, including educational institutions, sporting facilities, performance venues and situations connected with professional activities outside office premises.

The changes were significant because they recognised the changing nature of employment and the vulnerability of workers outside traditional organisational structures. However, the legal expansion has not removed the difficulties surrounding enforcement. The interpretation of the amended provisions has now become the subject of a major judicial and parliamentary dispute.

Federal Constitutional Court ruling sparks concern

On September 29, 2026, Dawn reported that the Federal Constitutional Court (FCC) had set aside an Islamabad High Court judgment in a workplace harassment case involving Nadia Sarwar, a female employee of the National Bank of Pakistan.

The dispute originated in 2012, when Sarwar complained against two colleagues, alleging sexual harassment and the misuse of professional authority. After initially approaching the bank’s management without receiving the relief she sought, she filed a complaint before the Federal Ombudsman in 2013.

The ombudsperson upheld her complaint and ordered compulsory retirement of the accused employees. However, subsequent proceedings before the President of Pakistan modified the penalty. Sarwar challenged that decision, and the Islamabad High Court restored the ombudsperson’s original order in December 2024.

The accused employees subsequently challenged the High Court’s decision before the FCC. The court, in its September 2026 ruling, interpreted the definition of harassment under Section 2(h) restrictively, holding that conduct must possess a sexual element to qualify as actionable harassment under the 2010 legislation.

The judgment stated that the definition was exhaustive rather than extensive and that the ombudsperson could not use the legislation to adjudicate general disciplinary misconduct lacking a sexual character. It also discussed the evidentiary requirements for establishing harassment.

The ruling triggered criticism from lawyers and journalists, who questioned its implications for the broader protections introduced through the 2022 amendments. Human rights advocates argued that an interpretation centred on sexual intent could leave victims of non-sexual gender-based discrimination without access to the statutory remedy.

The controversy also revived questions about the relationship between judicial interpretation and legislative intent, particularly when parliament has expressly amended a law to recognise conduct that extends beyond sexual harassment.

Parliament challenges the restrictive interpretation

The National Assembly’s October 30 resolution came against this background. Moved by Dr Shahida Rehmani, Secretary of the Women’s Parliamentary Caucus, the resolution reaffirmed parliament’s commitment to protecting individuals against workplace harassment and gender-based discrimination.

It specifically recognised intimidation, humiliation, degrading treatment, hostile behaviour and misuse of authority as forms of harassment, whether sexual or non-sexual. The resolution also referred to Articles 14 and 25 of Pakistan’s Constitution, which protect human dignity and equality before the law. It stressed that the absence of a sexual advance or demand should not diminish the seriousness of gender-based harassment.

The debate continued in November. On November 8, the National Assembly’s Special Committee on Gender Mainstreaming urged the federal government to vigorously pursue its review petition against the FCC judgment.

Attorney General Mansoor Usman Awan told the committee that the judgment appeared to have overlooked important legislative developments, particularly the 2022 amendment. He indicated that the government would seek reconsideration in light of the expanded statutory definition and earlier Supreme Court interpretations.

Federal Ombudsperson Fauzia Viqar also highlighted that requiring sexual intent for every harassment complaint would conflict with the amended legislation’s recognition of non-sexual gender discrimination.

Committee members raised concerns about the requirement for independent third-party corroboration, arguing that harassment frequently takes place in private or digital settings where witnesses may not be available. Such an evidentiary threshold, they warned, could discourage complaints and undermine access to statutory remedies.

The review proceedings have become central to the future interpretation of workplace harassment protections in Pakistan.

Complaint figures reveal the scale of the problem

The figures reported by the Federal Ombudsperson Secretariat for Protection against Harassment (FOSPAH) demonstrate the substantial number of complaints reaching the country’s statutory mechanism.

According to information presented to the National Assembly committee on November 8, FOSPAH had received 7,095 complaints since its establishment in 2010 and disposed of 6,944, representing a reported resolution rate of approximately 98 percent.

In 2025, the institution received 1,290 complaints and resolved 1,288, according to the committee’s briefing. The figures included complaints from federal entities and the provinces, with Punjab accounting for the largest reported share.

Separately, information presented to President Asif Ali Zardari in August 2026 showed that FOSPAH received 1,119 harassment complaints during 2024-25 and decided 1,047. It also received 352 complaints involving deprivation of property, deciding 238. Complaint registration reportedly increased by 375 percent compared with the preceding year.

A July report by Dawn, meanwhile, cited 1,290 complaints filed during 2025 and 1,104 resolved. Its geographical breakdown showed 727 complaints registered at FOSPAH’s Islamabad headquarters, 376 in Punjab, 90 in Karachi, 77 in Peshawar and 20 in Quetta. Both women and men approached the institution, although the gender distribution varied across locations.

These figures establish the volume of cases entering the formal system, but complaint disposal alone does not reveal the complete experience of victims. They do not necessarily establish how many complainants received satisfactory outcomes, how many faced retaliation, how long individual proceedings took or how effectively penalties were implemented.

A case marked as disposed of does not automatically establish that the complainant obtained lasting protection or that the institutional environment responsible for the complaint changed.

The silence surrounding retaliation and workplace power

One of the most persistent difficulties in workplace harassment cases is the imbalance of power between complainants and accused individuals. An employee reporting misconduct may have to approach the same management structure that controls their salary, promotion, professional reputation and continued employment. When the accused holds a senior position, the complaint can expose the victim to additional pressure.

The 2022 legislation recognises the vulnerability of complainants by extending protection to former employees who have resigned or been dismissed. It also includes students, domestic workers, freelancers and other individuals whose employment arrangements may not provide the security associated with permanent jobs.

However, the existence of these provisions does not establish that workers across Pakistan understand or can effectively access their rights.

The National Assembly’s November review itself acknowledged concerns about retaliation against complainants and witnesses. The committee emphasised the need for safeguards against such reprisals, reflecting the continuing importance of institutional power dynamics in harassment proceedings.

The problem also extends beyond formal offices. Domestic workers, students, performers, journalists, artists and people employed through informal arrangements may face harassment in environments where internal complaint committees are absent, ineffective or difficult to approach. For many such workers, the relationship between professional dependence and personal vulnerability can make reporting particularly difficult.

Widening gap between legislation and justice

Pakistan’s workplace harassment debate now involves more than the number of complaints filed or resolved. It concerns how the law is interpreted, the authority of statutory institutions, and individuals’ ability to obtain protection when professional power is used against them.

The 2010 legislation established a formal mechanism for addressing harassment. The 2022 amendments widened its scope, recognising that discrimination and intimidation could be gender-based without being sexual. However, the September 2026 FCC judgment has exposed a dispute over how those protections should be understood and applied.

The National Assembly’s subsequent resolutions and the government’s review petition have brought the issue back into the institutional spotlight, but the legal uncertainty remains significant. For employees confronting intimidation, humiliation or discriminatory treatment, the distinction between what parliament intended to prohibit and what the courts consider actionable can have direct consequences.

Pakistan’s workplace harassment crisis reflects a deeper problem than the absence of legislation. The country has laws, complaint mechanisms and oversight institutions, yet the experience of victims continues to be shaped by procedural barriers, institutional hierarchies and contested interpretations of legal protection.

Don't Miss

Pakistan Extends Financial Assistance to Replace Carpets at Grand Friday Mosque

The Pakistani government has provided financial assistance to replace the main hall

Off Sri Lanka, a High-Seas Drug Bust Catches the Couriers, Not the Bosses

COLOMBO, Sri Lanka — When the Sri Lanka Navy boarded a battered